Monday, September 19, 2005

Germany Struggles With Indecision

I read a lot of articles on the German election today. What a freakin' mess! This is now way to run a government and it makes me appreciate our political system. At the risk of insulting the intelligence of my readers, I think it may help many (including myself) if I break it down:

The German parliament is called the Bundestag. It currently has 617+ seats (this often flucuates for reasons that will be covered later), thus a political party or a coalition of parties need to have a little more than 300 seats in order to rule. The Chancellor is chosen by a majority vote of the Bundestag, much the way our House of Representatives elects a Speaker, thus if one party doesn't win more than 300 seats, political deals become vital. So, here's what happened in this weekend's election:

Christian Democrats (Merkel): 225 seats
Socialist Democrats (Schroeder): 222 seats
Free Democrats (Free-Market Capitalists): 61
Green Party (Environmental Wackos): 55 seats
Left Party (Commies and extreme nutjobs): 54 seats

So as you can see, no one party got over 300 seats, so a coalition must be formed. The Christian Democrats and the Free Democrats get along and would gladly form one, but that's only 286. The Socialist Democrats and the Greens like each other, but together they only make 277, and all four parties agree on one thing: they'd rather die than work in a coalition with the Left Party. The Christian Democrats said they would consider forming a coalition with the Greens; the Greens said forget it. The Socialist Democrats said they would consider a coalition with the Free Democrats who quickly told them to go pound sand. Thus, the only option left is what is known as a "Grand Coalition" in which the Christian Democrats and the Socialists Democrats would join together. This hasn't happened since the 1960s and is never an ideal form of government unless you like gridlock. The problem they're running into now is that both Merkel and Schroeder are saying they deserve to be Chancellor in such a coalition.

So what now? Well, the law states the Bundestag has three tries to elect a Chancellor. If they fail after two votes, the German Constitution says the Chancellor can be elected by a simple majority vote, which in this case would give the edge to Merkel. However, the President of Germany (a figurehead mostly, but crucial in this case) has the discretion to dissolve parliament and call for new elections if he feels the new Chancellor does not have the support of a majority of the Bundestag.

HOWEVER, this is complicated by the Dresden District and Germany's obscure "second vote" system. The election in Dresden was postponed to October 2nd because one of the candidates died recently. So, in order to give the fill-in candidate time to campaign, voting has been delayed for two weeks. While, it's only one seat, under the "second vote" system, Dresden could have as many as 4 seats.

When German's vote, they vote twice: once for a particular candidate and once for a particular party. It makes sense that if you like a candidate, you also like his party, but at times people split their votes. Thus, while a political party's candidates may not win so many seats, the party itself may win enough votes that it is determined that they deserve more seats in the Bundestag. These seats are called "overhang" seats. Therefore, all eyes are on Dresden. If enough people vote for the Socialist Democratic candidate and the party, Schroeder could have a majority of one. But again, it could be a mute point if President Horst Kohler decides it's hopeless and calls for new elections. Kohler is, for what it's worth, a conservative.

Is this the mosted F'd-up thing you've ever seen? Don't even ask how long it took me to write all this. Any one of these variables could change and Merkel is currently trying to fight off a party leadership challenge. Stay tuned...

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

Latest Buzz Video
Important Links

Pajamas Media BlogRoll Member

Brussels Journal
City Journal
Don Surber
Ed Driscoll
Fjordman
Front Page Magazine
Gateway Pundit
Hot Air
Instapundit
Iowahawk
Lileks - Bleat
Lileks - Screed
Michelle Malkin
People's Cube
Ron Radosh
Shannon Love
Seixon (Come back, Seixon!)
The Corner

Day by Day
RSS

 
Links
123beta
Ace of Spades
Alarming News
Ann Althouse
American Pundit
American Thinker
Anchoress
Ankle-Biting Pundits
Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
Anti-Strib
Are We Lumberjacks?
Astute Bloggers
Austin Bay
Babalu
baldilocks
Basil's Blog
Beldar
Best of the Web
Big Head DC
Bill Roggio
Biz Blogger
BizzyBlog
Blonde Sagacity
Blue Crab Boulevard
Brainwash Magazine
Brave New World
bRight & Early
Brothers Judd
Buzz Machine
Cafe Hayek
California Conservative
Captain's Quarters
Cassandra
Cato-at-Liberty
Chicago Boyz
Christopher Hitchens
Chronicle of the Conspiracy
Classical Values
Confederate Yankee
Conservative Blog Network
Cuanas
Daily Pundit
Daniel Pipes
Day by Day
D.C. Thornton
Democracy Reform
Democrats-Lie
Dick McMichael
Dissecting Leftism
DiveDesk
Doug Ross
Drew Cline
Dr. Sanity
Drudge
Dynamist
Erin Winking
Eject! Eject! Eject!
Evan Sayet
Flynn Files
Fore Left!
Founding Bloggers
Fraters Libertas
Free Thoughts
Gates of Vienna
Gay Patriot
GM's Corner
Girl on the Right
Global Warming Insanity
Heartless Libertarian
Hugh Hewitt
Iconic Midwest
IMAO
Iraq the Model
Israel Matzav
Jammie Wearing Fool
Jawa Report
Jihad Watch
Joe's Dartblog
John-diced Opinion
J$P
JunkYardBlog
Just A Girl In Short Shorts
JustOneMinute
Kaus Files
La Shawn Barber
Law Hawk
Liberally Conservative
Libertarian Leanings
Libertarian Republican
Lifelike Pundits
Little Green Footballs
Little Miss Attila
Lorie Byrd
Mark Steyn
Mary Katharine Ham
Michael J. Totten
Michael Yon
Media Mythbusters
Moonbat Monitor
Munchkin Wrangler
MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
Neo-Neocon
NewsBusters
Noisy Room
Odd Universe
Olbermann Watch
Other Side Of Kim
OxBlog
Patterico
Perfunction
Polipundit
Power Line
Professor Bainbridge
Protein Wisdom
Publius Pundit
Pundit Review
QandO
Radio Blogger
Radio Equalizer
Real Clear Politics
Red State
Right Place
Right Truth
Right Wing News
Right Wing Nut House
Roger L. Simon
Ron Rosenbaum
Rush Limbaugh
Samantha Burns
Samizdata
ScrappleFace
Sister Toldjah
Soccer Dad
Stop The ACLU
Strata-Sphere
Sundries Shack
Texas Rainmaker
The Nose On Your Face
TigerHawk
Tim Blair
Truth Laid Bear
TVNewser
Tygrrrr Express
USS Neverdock
Volokh Conspiracy
Wide Awakes
WILLisms
Wizbang
Wizbang Politics
Zombietime

Libertarianism
1975 Ronald Reagan Interview

Great Essays
Age of Post-Journalism
A Nicaraguan Tale
A Parliament of Clocks
Death of the American Idea
Democracy and Media Bias
Fear of Information
Postmodern Truth
Uncertain Uncertainty
Vietnam's Victory

Avant-Garde
Dead or Alive?
Elmyr de Hory
Jahsonic
Spaced
Syd Barrett
UBU

Oddities

The Botched Boobs of Tara Reid


Babe Theory of Revolution

Archives

June 2004

July 2004

August 2004

September 2004

December 2004

January 2005

February 2005

March 2005

April 2005

May 2005

June 2005

July 2005

August 2005

September 2005

October 2005

November 2005

December 2005

January 2006

February 2006

March 2006

April 2006

May 2006

June 2006

July 2006

August 2006

September 2006

October 2006

November 2006

December 2006

January 2007

February 2007

March 2007

April 2007

May 2007

June 2007

July 2007

August 2007

September 2007

October 2007

November 2007

December 2007

January 2008

February 2008

March 2008

April 2008

May 2008

June 2008

July 2008

August 2008

September 2008

October 2008

November 2008

December 2008
Powered By





Copyright 2008, Jim-Rose.com, The Libertarian Popinjay
Established June 20, 2004